After playing a pug on it, I have to say it would take a lot of getting used to, you're taking out a major proponent of the game, what with being able to clear commons as well as regular clearing (deadstops aren't so bad) and with a single pistol you will get wrecked by commons, I'd personally do three things.
1) Make it 2 swings, so that things like a missed pillpass wouldn't result in unneeded lolnomelee OR make it 3 seconds.
2) Put a SINGLE (or two) Melee in every saferoom, along with dualies. No melee spawns in map
3) make spitters die after a single shove, because at 5 seconds/shove she'd never die
Posted on Wednesday, 25th August 2010